Ireland has qualified for the World T20 in Sri Lanka, in
September. Ireland is on course to be in the World Cup in 2015. Ireland is the
team to beat, right now, at least amongst the Associate teams – the second tier
nations as judged by the ICC. So why haven’t they yet been granted full
membership of the International Cricket Council? The reason can only be because
such membership is almost tacit approval that they will then also, in due
course, become a test-playing nation.
 |
| Kevin O'Brien shows a level of delight after stuffing England. |
So, should they be allowed to play test cricket? Are there
too many teams already? And why do I sound like Carrie Bradshaw?
There are currently 10 nations with Test status. The
impression from my childhood is of each of the premier cricketing nations
touring England every four years (and vice versa) on a clear cycle. But then I remember Sri Lanka being added to
the elite group, followed by Zimbabwe and then Bangladesh and so gradually,
playing the old fashioned way, where nations tour each other every few years
has become increasingly difficult to sustain in any pre-defined roster. Added
to this are geo-political issues that have disrupted nations and, by
association, international cricket in recent years.
So can we add another team and stop trying to play all teams
all the time? And will this perhaps create some form of favouritism, a natural
selection if you like, whereby certain cricketing nations rise to the top of
the elite group and end up playing each other more often and effectively
creating a two tier “first division”? Well, this already happens of course – the
number of teams and the hunger for cricket in the Asian sub-continent makes
sure of that.
Cricket will never be a global game unless more teams join
the test playing countries – ok you’re right, cricket will never be a global
game, full stop – but in order to bring it to a wider audience and achieve more
credibility it needs to open up and doing so at Test level can’t harm the game
can it?
Well, diluting it with less competitive (test) teams could
do just that, but in any case it is a somewhat academic argument because of
course no team will ever be allowed into the elite group of test playing
nations without a first class structure in place, as the ICC believes it would
be an unsustainable model. So, unfortunately Ireland… sorry what’s that? Bangladesh
didn’t have one before becoming a test nation? Oh, well in that case bring on
Ireland.
In many sports I have been totally in favour of increased
elitism, it annoys me when I see an Olympic athlete languishing behind
the field simply because there was space for someone from his / her nation,
when a thousand other athletes around the world could be infinitely more
competitive but did not qualify for their respective nation. Eddie the Eagle,
was amusing, makes for good YouTubage, but if you were an 18 year old Finnish
Ski Jumper, who narrowly missed out on Olympic qualification what would you
think as you watched his antics?
I am not pretending to have anything other than double
standards, rather like the ICC, and I am not pretending to have answers
either! I was for a long time in favour of chopping out the "lower" footballing
nations at World Cups, narrowing the field and making the quality better but I
have to be honest and say that I have sort of come around to accepting it, and standards in the
World Cup as a whole are generally closer - although this may simply be down to many of the "bigger" footballing nations becoming increasingly shite and international football becoming so utterly dreary.
So, back to cricket. Come on ICC, bring Ireland into the “big
time”. Yes I want the Ashes home and away every four years, but then lets see
the likes of Bangladesh, Zimbabwe and Ireland visiting on a less regular basis.
More double standards I know, but who cares? No one would say that the Italian
rugby team doesn’t deserve its place in the 6 Nations and yet they generally
continue to struggle to beat most of the other 5 nations (Scotland... perhaps
you should also focus on cricket).